This is one of the most common questions I hear from the early-career families I work with. If you’re a dual-income household asking this question, you’re not alone. Between demanding careers, endless daycare waitlists, and the challenges of balancing work-from-home life with family responsibilities, many couples are wondering if it’s financially feasible for one spouse to step back from their career.
This isn’t just a financial decision—it’s a life decision that requires careful planning and honest conversations about your priorities, goals, and current financial reality.
Start with the End in Mind: What Really Matters?
Before diving into spreadsheets and budget calculations, take a step back and ask yourselves some deeper questions:
- How do we want to look back on this phase of our children’s lives?
- What does “success” look like for our family in 5, 10, or 20 years?
- Are we currently living the life we envisioned when we started our family?
- What trade-offs are we willing to make for more time together?
These qualitative factors are just as important as the quantitative ones. Financial security is crucial, but so is family time, reduced stress, and being present for the moments that matter most. There’s no “right” answer here—only what’s right for your family.
Consider where you are today: Are both parents constantly stressed, rushing between meetings and daycare pickups? Are you missing milestones because of work conflicts? Or perhaps you’re thriving in your current setup but curious about alternatives. Understanding your current reality helps you evaluate whether a change would improve your overall family well-being.
Conduct a Financial Audit: The Numbers Don’t Lie
Once you’ve clarified your priorities, it’s time to get specific about your finances. Let’s keep this simple but thorough.
Calculate Your Net Take-Home Pay
Start by determining each spouse’s actual monthly take-home pay—not gross income, but what hits your bank account after taxes, 401(k) contributions, health insurance, and other deductions.
For example:
- Spouse A: $8,500 net monthly
- Spouse B: $4,200 net monthly
- Total: $12,700 monthly
Analyze Your Monthly Expenses
Review the past six months of expenses to get an accurate picture. Don’t just estimate—use your bank statements, credit card statements, and budgeting apps to capture everything.
Consider how expenses would change if one spouse stops working:
Expenses that might decrease:
- Daycare: $2,500/month savings
- Commuting costs: $300/month savings
- Work lunches and coffee: $200/month savings
- Professional wardrobe and dry cleaning: $150/month savings
- Total potential savings: $3,150/month
Expenses that might increase:
- Groceries and household items: $300/month increase (more meals at home)
- Utilities: $75/month increase (more time at home)
- Activities and entertainment: $200/month increase (more family outings)
- Total potential increases: $575/month
Net change in expenses: $3,150 – $575 = $2,575/month in savings
Technology tools like Monarch Money, YNAB (You Need A Budget), or even your bank’s budgeting features can help you categorize and track these expenses more accurately.
Calculate Your New Cash Flow
Using our example:
- Current dual income: $12,700
- Minus Spouse B’s income: -$4,200
- Plus expense changes: +$2,575
- New monthly cash flow: $11,075
This means the family would have $1,625 less per month ($12,700 – $11,075) to work with—a much smaller gap than the initial $4,200 income loss.
Evaluate Your Benefits Situation
Benefits often represent a significant hidden cost that can make or break this decision.
Key questions to consider:
- Which spouse carries the health insurance, and what would it cost to switch?
- Are there Health Savings Account contributions you’d lose?
- What about life and disability income insurance through work?
- Will you lose access to a 401(k) match?
Example scenario: If Spouse B carried the family’s health insurance through work, you might need to switch to Spouse A’s plan. If Spouse A’s plan costs $800/month compared to Spouse B’s $300/month, that’s an additional $500/month expense you need to factor in.
Don’t forget about COBRA eligibility, which can provide temporary coverage but is typically expensive.
Assess Your Financial Foundation
Before making this leap, ensure your financial foundation is solid:
Emergency Fund
With one income, your emergency fund becomes even more critical. Aim for 6-9 months of expenses (rather than the typical 3-6 months for dual-income households). Using our example, with monthly expenses of $11,075, you’d want $66,450-$99,675 in emergency savings.
Debt-to-Income Ratio
Calculate your total monthly debt payments (mortgage, student loans, credit cards) as a percentage of your new single income. Ideally, this should be no more than 36% of gross income, including your mortgage.
Job Security
How stable is the working spouse’s employment? Consider industry trends, company performance, and personal job security. This transition is much riskier if the working spouse is in an unstable position.
Impact on Savings Goals
This is where the long-term implications become clear. Consider how this change affects:
Retirement Savings
- Will you still be able to max out retirement accounts?
- Are you losing a 401(k) match?
- Can you maintain your current retirement timeline?
Short and Medium-Term Goals
- College savings for your children
- Vacation home purchases
- Private school tuition
- Major home renovations
Example: If you were previously saving $3,000/month across all goals and now can only save $1,400/month, that $1,600 monthly difference equals $19,200 annually—a significant impact on your long-term wealth building potential.
Additional Considerations
Career Re-entry Planning
Discuss how and when the non-working spouse might return to work. Will they need retraining? How long might the career gap last? Consider the long-term earning potential impact.
Tax Implications
With one income, you might drop into a lower tax bracket, potentially reducing your overall tax burden. However, you’ll also lose the tax benefits of certain work-related expenses and potentially some tax-advantaged savings opportunities.
Childcare Backup Plans
Even with one spouse at home, you might still need occasional childcare for appointments, emergencies, or personal time. Budget for these costs.
Social and Professional Networks
Consider the non-financial impacts: social connections through work, professional development, and personal fulfillment from career achievement.
Making the Decision
This analysis should give you a clear picture of whether this transition is financially feasible and what adjustments you might need to make. Remember, this doesn’t have to be an all-or-nothing decision. Consider alternatives like:
- Reduced hours or part-time work
- Remote work arrangements
- Job sharing
- Taking a sabbatical with a planned return date
- One spouse transitioning to consulting or freelance work
Summary
Deciding whether one spouse can stop working requires both heart and head. Start by clarifying what matters most to your family, then run the numbers honestly. Calculate your actual take-home pay changes, factor in expense modifications, and carefully evaluate benefits costs. Ensure your financial foundation is strong with adequate emergency savings and manageable debt levels.
Most importantly, consider the impact on your long-term financial goals. While the monthly cash flow might work, the reduction in retirement and other savings can have significant long-term consequences.
This is a deeply personal decision that goes beyond spreadsheets. If the numbers work and align with your family values, it could be one of the best decisions you make. If they don’t quite work yet, you now have a clear picture of what needs to change to make it possible in the future.
The key is making an informed decision based on your complete financial picture, not just the immediate income change. With proper planning and realistic expectations, many families can successfully make this transition while maintaining their financial security and long-term goals.
The information provided in this article is for educational purposes only and should not be construed as financial or tax advice. Please consult with qualified financial and /or tax professional to discuss your personal situation. Any examples shown are for illustrative purposes only; your results will vary based on your personal situation.
CRN202710-8885065
